Photo — Taylor Swift: Taylor Swift (CC BY-SA 2.0) · Scooter Braun: Flickr (CC BY 2.0)

Music·Resolved·Since 2019
Beef Score measures the intensity and public prominence of a dispute. It does not indicate who is right.Factors considered·Heat·Public attention·Escalation·LongevityCurrently assigned editorially, not computed.

The Short Version

A dispute over ownership of an artist's early master recordings. In the sample scenario, a music executive acquires the label holding the artist's catalogue; the artist publicly objects, stating she was not given a fair opportunity to buy the masters herself. The executive's side disputes that characterisation. The disagreement matters because it made recording-contract ownership a mainstream conversation and prompted the artist to re-record her back catalogue. It ends when the catalogue is sold on to an investment firm and the artist proceeds with re-recordings.

Latest Development

Catalogue sold to an investment firm

Sample record: The masters were sold on to a third-party investment company, ending the direct commercial relationship between the two parties.

November 16, 2020 · Verified event

The Beef

Chronological, newest first. Every entry cites a source.

Beef timeline

  1. November 16, 2020

    Catalogue sold to an investment firm

    Verified event

    Sample record: The masters were sold on to a third-party investment company, ending the direct commercial relationship between the two parties.

    Sample Business Wire
  2. November 14, 2019

    Dispute over performance clearances

    Allegation

    Sample record: Swift alleged she was being blocked from performing her older songs at an awards show. The label publicly disputed the characterisation.

    Sample Trade Publication
  3. June 30, 2019

    Artist objects publicly to catalogue sale

    Public statement

    Sample record: Swift published a statement saying she had learned of the sale of her masters and had not been given a fair chance to buy them. Braun's side disputed that account.

    Sample Artist Statement

Where It Stands

Resolved. The catalogue changed hands and the artist completed several re-recordings. Neither party has continued the public argument.

Compare these two Beef networks →

Related Beefs

Same people, same category.

Sources

  1. 1.Sample Business WireCatalogue sold to an investment firm · Nov 16, 2020
  2. 2.Sample Trade PublicationDispute over performance clearances · Nov 14, 2019
  3. 3.Sample Artist StatementArtist objects publicly to catalogue sale · Jun 30, 2019

Allegations are attributed to the party that made them and are not statements of fact.